Wednesday, November 5, 2008
11
I believe that the film techniques in Triumph of the Will, were not really meant to show Hitler as a god, and I also believe that the film was NOT a propaganda film. I think that because the film was based on the Nuremberg Rallies, and because of what came out of those rallies, is why people thing that it is a propaganda film. The other week I watched the documentary, Woodstock, about the Woodstock 1969 music festival, and after doing a little research on the movie I found an interesting quote by the director Michael Wadleigh. He said: "Either this is going to turn into a riot, and be a documentary about how and why it happened, or this will be a documentary on one of the greatest things to ever happen." I think director Leni Riefenstahl had the same idea. Remember this is early 1930's while Hitler was coming to power, it was not known what he would do with the power he would gain, and you have to realize that even though his regieme turned out to be for evil, he empowered a nation, just like Barack Obama did during his presidental campaign. While I'm not comparing Obama to Hilter, I'm saying that they both did their job politically. It's sad, but try to play devil's advocate for a minute and imagine what Hitler could have done for good with the political power he had; everybody saw how many people were at the Nuremburg rallies, its obvious that if Hitler had been different, Germany as a whole could have gone a very different way.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
Matthew puts an interesting perspective to it, and I pseudo-agree with it.
I'm being a bit negative and still not totally buying into the idea that Reifenstahl was not a Nazi herself, sure now-a-days she won't claim to be, WHO WOULD?
But being in the time period of all of that and being a blonde woman herself I'm sure she at least got slightly into it.
Ok, I just read that her and Hitler had a keen friendship. I'm not TOTALLY off here.
Do the effects of this film shape politics today?
Did Triumph of the Will portray the rally as a religious experience?
Was the rally last night a religious experience?
Absolutely last night was a religious experience. I was fortunate enough to experience the speech with my friends whom I consider like-minded individuals and we were all entirely taken back by it.
I'm sure Germans experienced that same thing watching Hitler at his Nüremburg rallies. Detaching that feeling from the causes of Nazism allows you to view the film differently.
Post a Comment